Making Schools Work Better for All Children
 

 
About CER
 
  Home
  Mission
  Contact Us
  Search
 

Election Center

Education 2008: Where Has Reform Fared Well?

How to read this page:

The Center for Education Reform will help you understand where education reform has fared well as a result of the election returns.

We have summarized our observations about each state's new political climate based upon the outcome of elections for President, U.S. Senate, Governor and State Education Chief. If we regard the newly elected officials as a supporter of education freedom and accountability for America's school children then we believe the future is bright for education reform.

Our observations about each state's new political climate are symbolized by arrows pointing up or down to indicate either improving, declining or holding steady. Like a stock report which helps you place future investments, these indicators suggest in which states we believe parents, lawmakers and other concerned citizens are most likely to make a difference.

Click here for our Federal Snapshot
Click here for our State Snapshot

2008 EDUCATION REFORM ELECTION RESULTS:

State Legislation Changes (download) - U.S. Senate Results (download)
Governor Results (download) - State Education Chief Results (download)

Alabama
Reformer Jeff Sessions held onto his U.S. Senate seat.
Alaska
Alaskans will keep Sarah Palin at home but we're not so sure about Ted Stevens fate. Maybe he should give up his seat to the Governor?
Arizona
From a strong charter state, John McCain is headed back to the U.S. Senate and can be counted on to always support reformers.
Arkansas
Incumbent Mark Pryor returns to the U.S. Senate to continue his support for school choice.
Colorado
Mark Udall beat reformer Bob Schaffer to be the second Udall serving in the U.S. Senate for 2009. Udall was backed by unions, and opposes real school choice, so don't look for reformer votes here.
Delaware
Joe Biden. What more can we say? There is a moratorium on charters in this state with a strong charter law and the state's new governor now gets to fill Biden's modest reform shoes, which betting on his views, will not likely help our cause.
Georgia
Saxby Chambliss is a peach of a school choice supporter, but his re-election to the U.S. Senate is still up for grabs as they count votes. Meanwhile, his opponent Jim Martin scored a perfect zero for his reform support.
Idaho
Former Governor Jim Risch won the open U.S. Senate seat. We hope he continues his support for charters and choice.
Illinois
Incumbent Dick Durbin is likely to support the status quo however the election of Illinois' favorite son, Barack Obama, will encourage the party faithful to follow a new national leader.
Iowa
Sadly, for one of the lowest scoring choice states in the union, Iowans had little choice in their U.S. Senate race. Those who re-elected Tom Harkin to the U.S. Senate have chosen a nominal reformer.
Kansas
Incumbent Pat Roberts is a top reformer. His re-election to U.S. Senate is welcome in a state which needs improved educational opportunities.
Kentucky
Mitch McConnell's re-election to U.S. Senate is a key decider in both the future of nascent reform efforts in the state and a filabuster proof Senate.
Louisiana
U.S. Senator Mary Landrieu won a tight race for her re-election. This state has become a testing ground for innovative education reforms with her help and in Congress Landrieu is considered a leading spokesman.
Maine
Susan Collins has provided tepid support for reform. We hope with her re-election out of the way she'll grow stronger.
Massachusetts
John Kerry wins re-election but still fails to support major reform initiatives. We hope he decides to follow a new President's lead.
Michigan
U.S. Senator Carl Levin's votes rarely reflect the will of the people of his state whose strong support for reform puts it at the top of choice fans' lists.
Minnesota
Pro-reform Norm Coleman is locked in a recount with the totally establishment-focused comedian Al Franken. Franken's win would be our loss. We hope real reformers are monitoring the vote counters.
Mississippi
Double victories for reform minded incumbents. Thad Cochran and Roger Wicker return to the U.S. Senate. (Maybe they can do something about your state now?)
Nebraska
How many unicameral non-partisan legislatures does it take to bring interest in children's educational choices? At the federal level, Mike Johanns, U.S. Senate winner, should be a reformer.
New Hampshire  
Non-reformer Jeanne Shaheen wins her bid for U.S. Senate. Shaheen, the former Governor, set the tone for weak leadership on reform.
New Jersey
Frank Lautenberg returns to continue ignoring choice and opportunity from his lofty perch in the U.S. Senate.
New Mexico
The Udall family dynasty can't be broken. No new reformer here. Tom Udall is headed for the U.S. Senate.
North Carolina
Another non-reformer, Kay Hagan, is elected to the U.S. Senate taking out incumbent Liddy Dole.
Oklahoma
U.S. Senate incumbent Jim Inhofe won. He's a tiger for reform.
Oregon
Gordon Smith lost his U.S. Senate seat by a few votes to Jeff Merkley, someone who will fall in line against reform.
Rhode Island
Incumbent U.S. Senator Jack Reed isn't good on choice. The greatest little state in the union still needs a champion for school reform.
South Carolina
U.S. Senator Lindsay Graham was so assured of re-election that we last spotted him in Prescott, Arizona the night before. The Palmetto State voters know a good reformer when they see one.
South Dakota
The state from which incumbent U.S. Senator Tim Johnson hails has no charter law, no school choice, but at least Johnson offers modest support on the issues we hold dear.
Tennessee
Former U.S. Secretary of Education Lamar Alexander won his bid to return to the U.S. Senate. We look forward to seeing him again in Washington, D.C.
Virginia
What a difference a Warner makes. Mark Warner is a weak choice for education reform, but will now replace John Warner in the U.S. Senate.
West Virginia
U.S. Senator Jay Rockfeller owns this territory - it's just too bad he doesn't own the education issue.
Wisconsin
We won't badger you, there is nothing to say about any change coming in the political environment here. Too bad, this state brought us some of the most significant voucher victories in the nation.
Wyoming
Mike Enzi returns likely to be ranking Minority Leader on education again and a new sheriff from Wyoming is in town, John Brasso whose record, as of now, is unclear.

State Snapshot

Alabama
No races.
Alaska
Legislative composition has changed slightly but not enough to impact education reform - Palin has fewer Republicans in her legislature now but comes home renewed and refreshed to hopefully takle the issues she learned more about on the campaign trail...
Arizona
With Governor Napolitano being rumored to come to Washington in support of the President, a special election might usher in a new reform mentality. Reform may need a boost as the Republicans who traditionally supported reform now number fewer and so must work harder.
Arkansas
No change in this state, but change is overdue.
California
The Golden State has the same legislative composition as before; in his last two years, the Governator will hopefully pursue changes to help children still afflicted by bad policies.
Colorado
The more things change...
Connecticut
Snore... In a state known for its high ranking public schools, almost nothing happened in this election.
Delaware
Jack Markell's election to Governor will not improve the fate of school choice based upon his soft stance on accountability and outcomes, and his past support for the status quo. The Senate turned to Democratic hands and the House remained Democratic, so the question is whether any reform leaders will emerge to break with their party? This is a state for Democrats for Education Reform to challenge!
District of Columbia
In the District, the City Council acts as the legislature and this time around reform friends like Jack Evans and Marion Barry will be sure to keep the engines moving on progress in D.C. schools.
Florida
Other than hanging chads, no change to education reform came out of this election. But the status quo right now is good news in Florida where most of the leadership squarely supports reform.
Georgia
Besides the legislature which remains largely the same in composition, no other state offices were up for grabs. We'll look with hope to the next Governor's race, which needs a bit of a maverick to push stronger policies here.
Hawaii
Aloha and mahalo... We need to visit soon to be able to tell you if there's anything significant happening as a result of election day!
Idaho
This sleepy northwest state has actually made considerable progress expanding educational opportunities for children. Let's keep it that way.
Illinois
This state's favorite son could possibly influence policy here if he'll take a bold stance on reform. Something's gotta give.
Indiana
This bell weather state is important to presidential politics and education reform efforts alike. Tony Bennett as education chief will support incumbent Governor Mitch Daniels in his pro-reform stance. But, the Senate will need to be strong against the increasingly oppositional House.
Iowa
The epitome of Lake Wobegone. If these folks can caucus like it's a football game, why do they remain so complacent about shaking up the status quo?
Kansas
The Dustbowl kicked up nothing new here. Where is Toto when you need him?
Kentucky
Reformers in the Bluegrass State are whistling Dixie, but prepare for a major push this year for wholesale school reform.
Louisiana
Our pal Bobby Jindal must be relieved that neither he nor his legislature had to politick, giving them time to continue to transform the state's schools. But keep an eye on that Paul Vallas guy in New Orleans....
Maine
No news here, but we'd gladly take some for the education reform movement.
Maryland
Maryland, my Maryland! Without a race to watch, we're focused on 2010 and hope that something upsets the comfort of the Old Line State.
Massachusetts
Charters and standards are under attack by the sitting governor here and this year's legislative outcomes were uneventful. Nothing will happen of substance here until the grassroots mobilizes its energies forward.
Michigan
State legislative control remains split with the House run by Democrats and the Senate led by Republicans. Batter up!
Minnesota
Everyone's a comedian.
Mississippi
Only the U.S. Senate was in play this year. But, we'll be waiting.
Missouri
Show us the reformer, not Gubernatorial winner Jay Nixon who has vowed to veto any legislation that would expand education options. With the House and Senate in the hands of the opposite party, we pray that they keep hitting the ball to him so either Nixon blinks or takes a direct hit so some sense is knocked into him.
Montana
Incumbent Governor Brian Schweitzer wins re-election, but his party lost the Senate. For as much political activity as Montana will have seen in 2008, its citizens have yet to see an educational reform they are willing to adopt. We are cynical that will change, but we're will to try now that there's a little new blood in the State House. Sigh - the re-elected State Superintendent, though, is not a reformer.
Nebraska
How many unicameral non-partisan legislatures does it take to bring interest in children's educational choices? All we can say about this state is that there was an election. Maybe with the retiring of state board appointed Superintendent Christiansen we'll see some activity. We can dream can't we?
Nevada
Nevada Republicans lose the Senate to Democratic control, putting the only protection the state's charter schools and standards supporters have out to pasture. Maybe we'll have to play the tables to win some battles.
New Hampshire
Incumbent John Lynch, who has a track record made of granite when it comes to educational reform, won another term in the Governor's office and the legislature remains virtually the same.
New Jersey
The Garden State is up next year, but the Governor might come to D.C. to help the President. That would not be a huge loss to reform, in fact, a challenge to the state's methods for spending and controlling on all schools is overdue. Did someone say Wall Street?
New Mexico
No shifts here.
New York
Despite a pro-reform Governor in David Patterson, some are wondering what the switch in the Senate from Republican to Democrat will mean for breaking up public school bureaucracies. This was a clear win for the unions.
North Carolina
With Bev Purdue in the Governor's seat and June Atkinson as Education Chief, we're certain the restrictive charter cap is here to stay. The North Carolina Education Association is so proud that big daddy NEA came in to help them pound the pavement and elect pro-establishment candidates.
North Dakota
The re-election of Governor Hoeven does not improve the likelihood that school choice will be expanded in this rural state, which could really use the option. North Dakota is one of only ten states in the Union without a charter school law and this election did not change that fact. Wayne Sanstead won the race for State Education Chief.
Ohio
This is a strong charter state but presidential politics, which swung to the left, might just embolden anti-reform Governor Ted Strickland. The Ohio House loses its champion for choice, John Husted, as its leader now that Democrats are in control.
Oklahoma
Oklahoma Republicans took the Senate, which state reformers report is good news as it was split down the middle before, making progress next to impossible.
Oregon
Oregon's laid back attitude on reform will remain.
Pennsylvania
Another one to watch in 2010.
Rhode Island
We'll look to mayors here from now on to take the lead on any reforms.
South Carolina
No news here, though a few incumbents who have allowed new charters to be funded at half what other public schools are given should have lost their jobs.
South Dakota
No charter law. No school choice. No progress.
Tennessee
Tennessee reformers picked up friends in both Houses and it's the only state in the Union that went from being Democratic in the legislature to Republican. That doesn't necessarily mean a win for stronger charters and choice, but it's a start when the legislators are elected without the teachers' union's endorsement.
Texas
Texas is where it has been, but has never been as progressive as when our current President was there. Seriously.
Utah
We love Governor Huntsman and Utah voters do too. He's great for education reform and children. John Huntsman wins the Gubernatorial race, again.
Vermont
At the end of the day, incumbent Governor Jim Douglas wins another 4 years and the opportunity to reconsider his priorities and place education reform and children on his "to-do" list.
Virginia
The new Mayor of Richmond is open to charters, something we hope a new legislature in 2009 will usher in statewide.
Washington
Dino Rossi was a far better choice for our school children than Governor Christine Gregoire and her status quo approach to public education, but he lost again to the status quo and Gregoire. Reform lost an advocate when Randy Dorn beat Terry Bergeson for Education Chief.
West Virginia
Governor Joe Manchin won re-election so there is little hope for better schools in these hills.
Wisconsin
We won't badger you, there is nothing to say about any change coming in the political environment here. The House which is currently run by major league reformers just switched control from the Republican to the Democratic party, which once upon a time helped bring us some of the most significant voucher victories in the nation but has since left their principles behind.
Reform's a'comin'
Neutral
Negative

 

Education Reform 2008: A Voter's Guide (download complete PDF)

2008 Presidential Candidates Scorecard (click here)

2008 U.S. Senate Candidates Scorecard (download)

2008 State Executive Candidates Scorecard (download)

State Executive Election Profiles
Delaware
Indiana
Missouri
Montana
New Hampshire
North Carolina
North Dakota
Utah
Vermont
Washington
West Virginia

Resources:
Education Reform 2008: A Voter's Blog
Election Center 2008 Archives
Election Resources for Parents
Leaders Forum: Lessons from the States

The Center for Education Reform
910 Seventeenth Street, NW, Suite 1120 Washington, DC 20006
(tel) 800-520-2118 301-986-8088 (fax) 301-986-1826
 
cer@edreform.com www.edreform.com
copyright © 2008